Housewife fined $46k after maids spotted working on scaffolding outside Cluny Park house

Shaffiq Idris Alkhatib
The Straits Times
Aug 8, 2018

A housewife, whose maids were spotted last year perched on a two-storey scaffold while working on the facade of her Cluny Park house, was fined $46,000 on Wednesday (Aug 8).

Singaporean Willow Phua Brest, 46, pleaded guilty on Tuesday to four counts of failing to provide safe working conditions for her two Indonesian helpers, Ms Karsinah, 39, and Ms Dati, 43. She also admitted that she had unlawfully asked Ms Karsinah to perform tasks as a scaffolder and maintenance worker, the court heard.

The Straits Times understands that this is the first case in which a person is convicted for breaching work pass conditions involving the work safety of maids, after the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act was amended in 2012 with enhanced penalties.

Ministry of Manpower (MOM) prosecutor Shanty Priya said that the scaffold was erected at Brest's house on Oct 9 last year so that the second-storey windows could be cleaned.

The housewife then allowed her two maids to climb onto the structure and stand on it to clean the windows.

The Indonesians performed the task on Oct 11 and 13, with the help of safety belts, masks, gloves and an extended wiper.

However, Ms Shanty told District Judge Adam Nakhoda that the safety belts Brest provided were not sufficient to prevent or reduce the severity of injuries to the maids if they slipped off the scaffold. The prosecutor also stressed that the Indonesians were not trained to work at height.

That same month, Brest asked contractors to set up another scaffold at the back of her house for maintenance work. They declined to do so and instead, delivered to her home components for an unerected scaffold.

Investigations revealed that Brest then asked Ms Karsinah to perform tasks as a scaffolder and maintenance worker. However, the maid's work pass did not permit her to perform these tasks.

On Oct 20 last year, Brest asked Ms Karsinah to help her erect the scaffold and they took about three hours to set up the structure which was about 4.5m high.

After assessing that the scaffold was stable, the housewife asked Ms Karsinah to stand on it to sand, varnish and paint a wooden wall at the back of her house.

Ms Shanty said that the scaffold did not have required features such as proper guardrails.

In mitigation, defence lawyer Shashi Nathan told the court that there was no evidence that his client had forced the maids to step onto the scaffold. He also said that Brest had a good relationship with the maids.

The two women are no longer working for Brest. Ms Dati has since returned to Indonesia while Ms Karsinah is now working for another household here.

Read the full story on The Straits Times.

The Straits Times

Get a copy of The Straits Times or go to for more stories.